A French billionaire hunter is taking his fight global after California tax defeat
· Business Insider
STEPHANE DE SAKUTIN/AFP via Getty Images
- A 40-year-old French economist wants to put the world's billionaires on notice.
- Gabriel Zucman backed the California wealth tax before it was defeated at the polls.
- Now he's in Paris, rallying politicians to tax the super-rich, POLITICO reported.
Gabriel Zucman wants to put the world's billionaires on notice.
Visit freshyourfeel.org for more information.
The 40-year-old French economist, who has spent more than a decade designing ways to tax the ultra-rich, hosts a summit against "international oligarchy" in Paris on Saturday. It comes less than three weeks after California voters rejected a billionaire tax he backed, in a campaign where Google cofounder Sergey Brin and other opponents spent more than $300 million to thwart the initiative.
"Everywhere, we see very, very strong popular support for taxing billionaires," Zucman told POLITICO this week, arguing that his loss in California was only a minor setback. "That's true even in the United States."
Zucman sees fresh hope in the results of the US midterms, in which a string of Democrats campaigning to tax the ultra-rich won their races.
"Now our party has a choice to make: Are we going to stand with the working class or the tech lords?" said Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.), who is flying in for the Paris gathering. "The same inequality is fueling anger and distrust not only in America, but also in France and around the world," he told POLITICO.
Khanna and Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.) are due to speak at the Théâtre de la Concorde, a city-owned venue off the Champs-Élysées loaned for the occasion by Emmanuel Grégoire, the socialist mayor of Paris.
Left-wing leaders from Italy, Brazil, Spain and the UK are also expected to attend. A "Paris Manifesto" published Friday calls for a minimum tax on the largest fortunes, protections for independent media and rules for artificial intelligence.
The question is whether anyone outside the theater will buy into Zucman's ideas. His signature proposal, a minimum annual tax of 2% on the largest fortunes, was rejected by the French Senate last year.
"It's a real program to save our democracy," said Eva Joly, a former French investigating judge who jailed the boss of oil giant Elf in the 1990s and later served as a European lawmaker for the Greens. Zucman "carries it brilliantly," she told POLITICO.
The fight goes on
Global talks on taxing the super-rich have stalled this year under the US presidency of the G20, according to Zucman, who expects the impasse to persist as long as Donald Trump is in the White House. Still, he hopes to revive the debate when Britain takes over the G20 presidency next year.
In Brussels, meanwhile, tax legislation generally requires the unanimous agreement of all 27 EU governments, making a bloc-wide solution difficult.
Rather than wait for international agreement, Zucman expects individual governments to take the lead, just as France did with value-added tax in the 1950s and several EU countries have done more recently with digital services taxes.
Bills to tax the wealthy are in the works in the Netherlands, Belgium and Spain, he said, while the British government has begun looking at the idea.
Joly is less ready to write off Brussels, calling the EU "a field of possibilities." She argued that low taxes on multinationals distort competition with domestic firms and said it was the responsibility of the European Commission and Parliament to address the problem.
There are also signs of movement on corporate taxation. European Council President António Costa is weighing a tax on US tech giants to help fund the EU's next seven-year budget, POLITICO reported Thursday, after Trump's poor showing in the midterms eased fears of retaliation by Washington.
"Europe cannot afford to calibrate its tax policy to America's mood swings," said Paul Monaghan, chief executive of the UK-based Fair Tax Foundation, which campaigns on corporate tax conduct.
At the United Nations, negotiators will meet in Nairobi from November 30 to December 10 for the next round of talks on a global tax convention, with a final text due in 2027.
Beyond the left
In California, Zucman said, billionaires flooded voters with "disinformation" that the tax would bankrupt the health system, even though 90% of the revenue raised would have gone toward health care.
But money was only part of the story. Unions split over the measure, POLITICO reported, and Gov. Gavin Newsom campaigned against it. A state-only wealth tax "creates economic incentives for money and jobs to leave the state," his chief of staff, Nathan Barankin, said.
Zucman rejects the notion that Saturday's gathering is a rally of the left. He said he had invited former EU competition chief Margrethe Vestager and former Italian Prime Minister Mario Draghi, but both declined. A spokesperson for Vestager declined to comment.
Yet in France, the far-left France Unbowed party and the Greens were the only ones to fully embrace Zucman's proposed 2% annual wealth tax ahead of next spring's presidential election. MEP Raphaël Glucksmann, who is running for a left-wing coalition that includes the Socialists, has instead proposed to raise the tax rate for inheritances above €1.8 million, and a one-off 5% levy on fortunes over €100 million.
François Geerolf, an economist at Sciences Po's OFCE, has challenged Zucman's arguments. In a paper updated last month, he argued that Zucman had exaggerated the extent to which billionaires are undertaxed and proposed a remedy that could do more harm than good.
Geerolf acknowledged that the ultra-rich can use holding companies to shield income from taxation, but argued for closing the loophole instead of imposing an annual tax on fortunes. He also questioned estimates that the tax would raise €20 billion a year in France, putting the likely proceeds at just €2 billion to €6 billion. His verdict: "A real problem, a false diagnosis, a bad remedy."
Other critics have also been mobilizing. Trop c'est trop ("Enough is enough"), a campaign group backed by business executive Eric Maumy, presented a study Wednesday characterizing Zucman's tax proposal as confiscatory and unconstitutional.
But Zucman believes it is the status quo that is untenable. "Do you think it's normal that billionaires can pay zero personal tax?" he said. "It's the current situation that is radical."
The Axel Springer Global Reporters Network harnesses the resources of the company's newsrooms to publish ambitious scoops, investigations, interviews, opinion pieces and analysis. It allows journalists — including those from POLITICO, The Telegraph, Business Insider, WELT, BILD, Onet and Fakt — to collaborate on major stories for an international audience of hundreds of millions across platforms: online, print, TV and audio.
Read the original article on Business Insider