'There is no SEC bias’ they said': Jake Butt torches CFP committee after third rankings

· Yahoo Sports

Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

Of all the places Jake Butt might have expected his Michigan philosophy coursework to resurface, a Big Ten Network breakdown of the College Football Playoff rankings probably wasn’t near the top of the list, but the selection committee’s latest top 25 gave him every reason to head back to Ann Arbor.

Visit tr-sport.bond for more information.

Reacting to the third installment of the rankings, the former Wolverines tight end recounted a lesson on Aristotle and the origins of circular reasoning, then explained how he sees that same flawed logic at work in the way the committee props up the SEC.

“This went like, ‘Hey, my teacher is good because he is wise,’ and they said, ‘Well, how do you know your teacher is wise?’ ‘Well, my teacher is wise because he is good,'” Butt said. “Why do I say that? Because that’s exactly what we’re seeing with these rankings and how the committee uses the SEC.”

Butt’s most damning evidence was hiding in plain sight at the tail end of the committee’s Nov. 17 release, where four of the final five spots belonged to SEC teams with identical 6-4 records

The committee slotted South Carolina at No. 21, Oklahoma at No. 22, Florida at No. 24, and Ole Miss at No. 25 — all four sporting matching 6-4 records — while 7-3 Louisville sat at No. 23 as the lone interloper in an otherwise wall-to-wall SEC stretch. Oklahoma and Florida both cracked the rankings for the first time this season after LSU, Missouri, and Oklahoma State were jettisoned from the top 25, and South Carolina and Ole Miss somehow clung to their spots even after sliding four and six places, respectively.

“Why is there no 6-and-4 Big Ten teams ranked, Rick? I don’t know, but clearly this is being done to boost the resume of some SEC teams,” Butt told his colleague, Rick Neuheisel. “I think a lot of these Big Ten teams are being disrespected.”

The résumé-boosting Butt described works like a feedback loop, in which middling SEC teams stick around in the top 25, turn into quality wins for the conference rivals that beat them and keep those rivals firmly planted near the top. No team has benefited more than Alabama, which held at No. 3 with an 8-2 record — the highest a two-loss team has ever been ranked in a season’s third rankings, per the CFP’s own release — despite going just 2-2 against the current top 25. Tennessee, meanwhile, beat Alabama head-to-head in Knoxville in Week 7 and still finds itself stranded six spots behind the Crimson Tide at No. 9.

The committee’s loyalty to Alabama looked even harder to justify given how it handled Indiana just a week earlier. The defending national champions went into their Week 10 bye at No. 4 and came out of it at No. 9, with committee chair Hunter Yurachek chalking up the five-spot drop to a packed weekend that featured seven games within the top 25. Yurachek called Indiana “probably the victim of having a bye week at the wrong time,” but that explanation did little to placate Curt Cignetti, who spent the following days needling the committee over the slide.

As far as Butt was concerned, the committee had a ready-made reason to knock Alabama down a peg this week, only to conveniently shelve the same standard it had leaned on seven days earlier to justify dropping Indiana.

“So last week we’re saying, man, how does Indiana drop after a bye? Well, because some of their good wins lost,” Butt said. “Well, OK, let’s go back to Alabama. All six of the SEC teams that Alabama has beat this year, they all lost this weekend, and yet Alabama still does not move again. It just, I’m struggling to make sense of these rankings.”

Butt carried his grievances to X, where he contrasted the garden-variety gaffes every broadcaster commits on live television against what he sees as the rankings show’s weekly habit of outdoing its own absurdity.

Butt is far from the first to roll his eyes at the weekly ESPN reveal, which has drawn growing criticism over who the rankings show is really serving, but few have put it quite as colorfully as he did in his next post.

As Butt pointed out in another post, there’s a lot more than pride on the line when the committee gets these rankings wrong, and the stakes are about to grow considerably. ESPN and the CFP made the 24-team playoff official earlier this month, with the network agreeing to pay an extra $345 million a year on top of the $1.3 billion it already spends on the event. With conference championship games going away to make room for the bigger bracket, where a team lands in the rankings — and whether that means a bye, a home game or a favorable first-round draw — is about to matter more than ever.

Butt’s concerns about subjectivity aside, the Big Ten is far from frozen out, with undefeated UCLA sitting pretty at No. 4 and Ohio State jumping six spots to No. 14 at 7-3 as one of six conference teams in the top 25. But there are only two rankings shows left before the bracket is set on Dec. 6, and unless the committee comes up with a better explanation than the ones it’s offered so far, Butt seems ready to keep insisting the sky is blue.

The post Jake Butt rips CFP committee’s ‘circular reasoning’ with SEC: ‘I’m struggling to make sense of these rankings’ appeared first on Awful Announcing.

Read full story at source