LILLEY: Canadian steel sector left exposed by Mark Carney’s China deal
· Toronto Sun

See more Toronto Sun on Google — save as a Preferred Source
Visit afsport.lat for more information.
Just under a month ago, Mark Carney was promising billions in help for Canadian steel producers and protection from unfair dumping. Now, he’s agreed to let in more Chinese steel and aluminum products as part of his latest trade deal with Chinese President Xi Jinping .
Carney not only agreed to extend existing remissions for Chinese steel products subject to a 25% tariff, he’s extending them to 23 more steel products and nine aluminum products. This makes these products effectively tariff-free.
Which wouldn’t be a problem if China were a free-trading, market-based economy, but it’s not. China subsidizes its companies in a number of ways. In fact, according to the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, Chinese steel firms receive 10 times more government support than steel firms in an OECD country like Canada.
It’s tough to compete when your competitor relies on the government.
Billions promised, protections removed
By extending and expanding these remissions, Carney is asking Canadian steel companies to do just that while also asking them to retool and start making more products. These remissions, he claimed, are only for products where “Canadian supply is insufficient or unavailable.”
Who is going to make these products in Canada when they have to compete against cheaper options subsidized by Beijing?
In October, Carney stood with Ontario Premier Doug Ford in Ottawa to announce their new Joint Steel Action Fund. The $5.43-billion fund saw the feds put up $3.55 billion and the province $1.67 billion to help steel companies diversify their products.
“We have the best steel workers in the world. We have vast natural resources. Yet we import over 6.5 million tons of steel a year. And that’s often because we don’t make the steel that Canadian companies need,” Carney said on Oct. 21.
“It’s time to be our own best customer. And so today’s investment will enable mills and companies to upgrade machinery and manufacture more products.”
A month ago, Carney said we needed to make more of these products in Canada. Now, he’s removing tariffs on the very products Canadian firms are supposed to be retooling to produce, putting them at an unfair disadvantage.
Make no mistake: If a Canadian steel firm retools, these tariffs won’t be going back on. Carney is too busy boasting that he traded this steel access for pork and fish access to China.
If I were a steelworker or the premier, I’d be furious with Carney over this deal.
RECOMMENDED VIDEO
A warning for autoworkers
Steel workers should see this as a warning. Auto workers should see it as a preview.
How can autoworkers trust that Carney and his team have their best interests and their future at heart when he has just betrayed Canada’s steel sector?
The moves Carney is making will also make it much more difficult to secure a trade deal with the United States. The Americans have been concerned about China dumping steel into the North American market and hurting their industry for more than a decade now.
We are going to let them dump more products into our market, which will make the U.S. question the wisdom of granting us favoured access to their steel market.
On autos, the Americans have been rightly concerned about Chinese vehicles for many reasons.
The concerns about these vehicles being connected to servers in Beijing and relaying data back to China are valid. These are concerns that have been shared by the British, Germans, Norwegians, Israelis and others.
Playing with America’s patience
The impact of Chinese auto assembly in Europe and South America should also serve as a warning. China only assembles kit cars in foreign markets, meaning mostly assembled vehicles receive final assembly there.
In Europe and South America, the result is tens of thousands of jobs lost as Chinese firms gobble up market share without replacing the jobs they have eliminated.
Carney should know this, but it seems he is determined to show the Americans that, under his leadership, Canada doesn’t need the U.S.
Eventually, with moves like this, the U.S. might decide they don’t need us. And when that day comes, it won’t be Washington scrambling to find a new customer.